IdeaSift

DIY finance users struggle to find apps that fit and last

People managing their personal finances want software that is easy to use, flexible enough for their needs, and dependable over time. Some fall back to spreadsheets because apps feel tedious or incomplete, despite the manual work; another user worries that a subscription service could close and take their work with it. A standalone, portable finance tool could address much of this, though it cannot fix a bank's own app performance or make search results better.

For DIY personal finance managers. Mentioned from Mar 2024 to May 2026 on Hacker News.

5 different people described this problem in 5 separate discussions.

Week of 2026-07-13: 0Week of 2026-07-20: 0Week of 2026-07-27: 0Week of 2026-08-03: 0Week of 2026-08-10: 0Week of 2026-08-17: 0Week of 2026-08-24: 0Week of 2026-08-31: 0Week of 2026-09-07: 0Week of 2026-09-14: 0Week of 2026-09-21: 0Week of 2026-09-28: 0
0 mentions in the last 12 weeks
Indie fit
4.0/10
Pain
5.6/10
Frequency
6.5/10
Willingness to pay
0.0/10
Momentum
5.0/10
Who pays
Consumers
Competition
High
Build difficulty
Medium

What people said

Quoted word for word. Follow a link to read the whole discussion.

  1. Same here. I still haven’t found a single app that does everything I need, so I end up using a spreadsheet and updating it manually. It’s flexible and transparent, but also tedious, which is why I keep looking for a better tool that doesn’t get in the way
    HanaStan on Hacker NewsJan 2026Has a workaroundAsked for a tool
  2. You play the good customer, pay for years, and then it closes down and you have nothing to show for it. Garbage. Excuse me while I slink back to my spreadsheet
    datavirtue on Hacker NewsMar 2024Has a workaround
Build brief

See what to build and who will buy it

  • 1 product idea with the smallest useful version and pricing
  • 4 places to find your first customers
  • 3 more quotes from people who have this problem
  • Current workarounds, existing solutions and risks